LIRR → Penn Station
$676/mo
57 min one-way · $15.37/trip incl. kiss-and-ride (drop-off) access (peak fare $15.25)
$3,985 /mo
$47,824/yr — all-in to live in Hicksville, NY and commute to Manhattan
(utilities-full, HUD-AMI bracket)
housing $2,357
+ utilities $694
(Nassau County county level)
+ commute $934
(Hicksville station, household)
✓ TLC-affordable — 29.1% of HUD AMI (FY2026, $164,300, utilities-full)
Nassau County: metro tier 4/5 (at HUD AMI × utilities-full)
Components rounded to the dollar; the total is computed before rounding.
It costs about $3,985 a month to live in Hicksville NY and commute to
Manhattan (rail), per the True Lifestyle Cost Index — $2,357 housing + $694
utilities (both measured at the Nassau County county level) + $934 household commute via
the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) from Hicksville station to Penn Station, Manhattan ($676/mo per commuter,
57 minutes one-way, × 1.38 workers per household). Driving the same commute would cost
$2,453/mo per commuter including tolls, the $9 NYC congestion charge, Midtown parking and fuel —
rail saves $1,777 a month per commuter.
Source: True Lifestyle Cost Index v1 (TLCengine, June 2026) — commute priced from posted
fares, tolls, congestion charge, parking and fuel effective June 2026; housing/utilities: ACS 2020–2024, DOE LEAD
2022 trended to EIA 2026, FCC URS 2026, BLS CEX 2024; income basis HUD FY2026.
Rail vs drive from Hicksville, per commuter
drive all the way
$2,453/mo
82 min one-way · $55.76/trip incl. tolls, $9 congestion charge, parking, fuel
rail saves
$1,777/mo
$21,326/yr per commuter — and the train is 25 min faster one-way
22 round-trips a month at the 8:00 am peak. Rail is the chosen (cheaper) mode in all 30 towns this index computes — metro-wide it saves $1,635–$2,429 a month per commuter. Annualized, Hicksville’s rail savings of $21,326 is real mortgage capacity — roughly the payment on $260K of additional loan at recent ~7% 30-year rates.
What each component is — and where it’s measured
| Component | $/mo | Geography | Source (vintage) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Housing (shelter) | $2,357 | Nassau County (county) — town-level H is a v2 item | ACS 2020–2024, tenure-weighted, embedded utilities stripped |
| Utilities (full) | $694 | Nassau County (county), HUD-AMI bracket; broadband state, water/cell national | DOE LEAD 2022 × EIA 2026 + FCC URS 2026 + BLS CEX 2024 |
| Utilities (energy-only) | $412 | Nassau County (county) | benchmark-comparable figure |
| Commute (household) | $934 | Hicksville station (town) × county workers/HH (1.38) | computed door-to-door: posted LIRR fare, access leg, June 2026 |
| Commute (per commuter) | $676 | Hicksville station (town) | $15.37 × 2 × 22 days |
| True Lifestyle Cost (household) | $3,985 | mixed — labeled above | housing + utilities (full) + household commute |
This town page joins county-level housing and utilities (town-level H/U land with the tract build — LEAD tract energy is already staged) with a town-level computed commute from Hicksville station. HUD income-limit area: Nassau-Suffolk, NY HUD Metro FMR Area. Income basis here is the county’s HUD FY2026 AMI ($164,300); for the median / HUD-80% / custom-income view of the same dollars, use the Nassau County page.
Questions people ask
- How much does it cost to live in Hicksville, NY and commute to Manhattan?
- About $3,985 a month all-in, as of June 2026: $2,357 housing + $694 utilities (both Nassau County county level) + $934 household commute by the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) from Hicksville station (True Lifestyle Cost Index v1, HUD-AMI basis: 29.1% of income).
- Is it cheaper to drive or take the train from Hicksville to Manhattan?
- The train: LIRR costs $676/mo per commuter (22 round-trips) versus $2,453/mo driving — tolls, the $9 congestion charge, parking and fuel included. Rail saves $1,777 a month — and the train is 25 min faster one-way.
- How long is the commute from Hicksville to Penn Station?
- 57 minutes one-way by the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) from Hicksville station; driving takes about 82 minutes at the 8:00 am peak.
- What salary do you need to live in Hicksville and commute to Manhattan?
- About $99,600 a year keeps the all-in cost ($3,985/mo) at or under the 48% affordability line of the True Lifestyle Cost Index.
Nearby commute towns: Great Neck, NY · Mineola, NY · Freeport, NY · Hempstead, NY · Massapequa, NY · County: Nassau County, NY
About the True Lifestyle Cost Index™. The True Lifestyle Cost Index is an independent affordability index published by TLCengine, computed from U.S. Census American Community Survey data, U.S. DOE and EIA energy data, HUD income limits, FCC and BLS consumer surveys, and TLCengine’s own door-to-door commute-cost engine. Krishna Malyala, broker, NMLS #1875937.
Not affiliated with CNT. TLCengine and the True Lifestyle Cost Index are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by the Center for Neighborhood Technology. H+T® is a registered trademark of the Center for Neighborhood Technology; where shown, H+T® Index data is © CNT (htaindex.cnt.org) and is used solely for comparison, with attribution. The True Lifestyle Cost Index does not republish CNT data.
Income limits. “HUD AMI” figures are HUD FY2026 area median family incomes and published income limits (huduser.gov); they are 4-person family benchmarks and differ from median household income.
Not financial advice. Estimates for research and comparison; verify fares, tolls, housing and utility costs before transacting.